It is the most fantastic time of the 12 months, Bachelor Nation. On June 7, ABC dropped The Bachelorette Year 17 premiere, and several followers are now theorizing who wins Katie Thurston’s heart. But for those people of us who can’t pick up all the night one particular clues, we have Jimmy Kimmel and his wife, Molly McNearney, who have been predicting The Bachelorette winner for decades. So who did the late-night time host guess as Katie’s final decide and top 4? Here’s what went down and what the new lead shared about her ending.

Jimmy Kimmel’s modern ‘Bachelorette’ and ‘Bachelor’ winner predictions

‘The Bachelorette’ star Katie Thurston on ‘Jimmy Kimmel Stay!’ | Randy Holmes/ABC by means of Getty Photos

Related: The Bachelorette Katie Thurston Reveals the ‘Hardest Thing’ She Did on the Exhibit